Showing posts with label neobux. Show all posts
Showing posts with label neobux. Show all posts

Thursday, March 31, 2011

Et Tu, NeoBux? -- APRIL FOOLS!

I'm not sure whether to be scared, or really amused. The cash and ads are showing in roman, though when you mouse-over, they display back as normal.


It's April Fools! And, by the way, Golden's become Supervisor, and Ultimates become President!

Pioneers become Ancient.

Not sure what Help desk is.



And guess what the admin is!


It's hard to be annoyed at this guy :P
I'm liking his humor.

Tuesday, March 29, 2011

NeoBux: Remember The $0.50 ticket?

Well, it's real.



I'm not sure what to make of that. But, if it's a regular occurrence, that would definitely be something to add against expenses. Lots of changes are happening... not sure yet if it's a good idea to stay. Will keep clicking until I've decided. Funny, though, how the improvements are offered slowly, while the one huge disappointment is dropped at the turn of a dime. Funny, innut... Oh, I know, admin, I know - it's because of "the reaction" to it. Either you're a schmuck (one with good intentions, of course), an idiot (again, one with good intentions, of course), or a scammer. Time will tell.

(Couldn't find the original post, so I'll post PTC-I's)
http://ptc-investigation.com/NeoBux.aspx
"9. Bonuses - For each advertisement you see you'll have an opportunity to earn $0.50 each hour. If you've seen advertisements in the past hour, you're eligible for the draw. This amount will be added to the main balance and users can do what they want with it."

Friday, March 25, 2011

NeoBux: A Turn for the Better

http://www.neobux.com/forum/?frmid=3&tpcid=197925

"Looking back almost 2 weeks ago, where the first and required step of the process was implemented, and recalling the chaos created by those who fear changes even though proven successful, I will take it easy this time."

"All the needed changes were to be ready until month's end and would turn NeoBux into the most perfect place to be BUT I won't take the risk, even though I'm perfectly sure everyone would love it, to make these radical changes all at once. I understand that some need time to digest changes and evolve with them. I understand and accept it. It's even better to have a surprise every now and then than to risk some having a heart attack for looking at something wonderful that was appeared overnight."

"Instead of a global instant change you'll benefit from the new model one feature at a time until we can finally conclude all changes."

"New features will be introduced as soon as the current ones are fully understood by our users."

THANK YOU. Although, I don't appreciate your inane characterization:
"having a heart attack for looking at something wonderful that was appeared overnight."
No, no, and no. But whatever. You can view it however you like so long as you're actually listening. Or do you REALLY think that users thought that earning $0.001 instead of $0.01 was "looking at something wonderful"?

Tuesday, March 15, 2011

NeoBux - Frontier Psychologist: "How do you feel today?"

Cue Frontier Psychologist:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U8BWBn26bX0

"How do you feel today?"
"Poll Question:
This poll is being made to know EXACTLY how our users feel about the new changes.
Why? Because what some wrote is completely different from what's happening and, although I see everything is getting better, I need to be absolutely sure and users will also get a general idea.
I know that many misunderstood the changes at first and needed to see the reality for themselves which is why this poll was only created now, 48 hours after the changes.

The question is simple:

ARE THE NEW CHANGES BETTER FOR YOU?
or
DO YOU LIKE THE NEW CHANGES?

This topic is closed to avoid spammers but you can vote.
It will be closed in a few hours, as soon as a significative amount of votes is gathered. A new topic will then be created to discuss the results.


Answers:
1: Yes
2: No"

http://www.sing365.com/music/lyric.nsf/frontier-psychiatrist-lyrics-the-avalanches/23d0c706ca58bab548256a7e002af621
"Is NeoBux ill, Is NeoBux ill, Is NeoBux ill
Is NeoBux ill today, Mr Kirk, NeoBux's in school
I'm afraid he's not, Miss Fishpaw
NeoBux's truancy problem is way out of hand
The Baltimore County school board have decided to expel
NeoBux from the entire public school system


Oh Mr Kirk, I'm as upset as you to learn of NeoBux's truancy
But surely, expulsion is not the answer!
I'm afraid expulsion is the only answer
It's the opinion of the entire staff that NeoBux is criminally insane

That boy needs therapy, psychosomatic,
That boy needs therapy, purely psychosomatic
That boy needs therapy
Lie down on the couch! What does that mean?
You're a nut! You're crazy in the coconut!
What does that mean? That boy needs therapy
I'm gonna kill you, that boy needs therapy
Grab a kazoo, let's have a duel
Now when I count three
That, that, that, that, that boy.. boy needs therapy
He was white as a sheet
And he also made false teeth


Frontier Psychiatrist
Frontier, frontier, frontier, frontier
Frontier, frontier, frontier, frontier
Frontier, frontier, frontier, frontier


That boy needs therapy, psychosomatic
That boy needs therapy, purely psychosomatic
That boy needs therapy
Lie down on the couch, what does that mean?
You're a nut! You're crazy in the coconut!
What does that mean? That boy needs therapy"

I'm not going to answer the question. To anyone who has reading these posts, the answer is obvious.
So, NeoBux, how do you feel about that? Are your doubts about your sheep gone?

Monday, March 14, 2011

A Strategic Death For NeoBux?

An excellent commentary, in my opinion:
By SadDayForNeo
http://ptc-investigation.com/neobux.aspx
"Until now, Neobux had shown more skill than all the other ptc sites out there, but with this latest move we finally see clear evidence that Neobux is in trouble. 
What is the proof ? Because admin is sharply reducing all the click rates that are a DIRECT EXPENSE for him. The click rates on his own ads (which has always been a way to attract customers to make affiliate commissions for his own account ), the direct ref clicks. 
So why is he leaving the rented ref clicks at the same level ? Because they are NOT an expense to him ! The refs you rent on the site are mere BOTS, and their average click rates are entirely manipulated by the script - The admin allows only a select minority to make a profit on rented refs, and those are the people who have already invested substantially in the site. For the rest of us, he sets the click rates so that we are either break even, or make a slight loss, so that he does not lose a penny. I was a golden member for a year, and after a couple of months it became clear to me that even though daily click numbers varied wildly, their average always ended up by some incredible coincidence very close to my purchase price, and that level would hold steady for months on end ! Such things do of course not occur by chance, but because the script is programmed in that way… 
Bye bye Neobux, this is the first nail in the coffin, turning you for now into an Aurora site. When will the next shoe drop ?"

And combine with that his evasive and condescending answers, and you have
THE NEXT BUX.TO! Great.


Awww! Look at one of the True Believers:
"Thank's  Admin .

This poll show's you're always here to build a hand-by-hand busyness.

I believe those changes will be nice but we all know that's a long way to walk.
I don't mind that 30.000 unbeliever's leave.

Those were the ones who never understood NEOBUX, those were the one's who click casually, so I don't mind they leave as I don't mind to earn less from Fixed advertisements.

My ref's are still clicking, less, but they're clicking and I earn the same.

Thanks for sharing profit's with us   Admin .


ROCK'S"

Soooo cute! Think the meat will taste delicious?

And a cute-funny one:
"I have suggestion:

0,0000000001$ for Fixed advertisements
0,0000000000$ for Mini Exposure
0,0000000000$ for Micro Exposure

0,0000000000000000000001 for direct referrals
0,0000000000000000000000 for rented referrals

1000$ for sign in
5000$ for upgrade
9999$ for ultimate

1.000.000$ minimum withdraw

Advertisers will be happy
Admin will be happy
Owner will be happy

Rest of us? Who cares"

Proudly Banned From NeoBux's Forums[?]

Apparently, I've been temporarily banned from the forum. I really don't give a fuck. I'm tired of the place. I've said what I have to say. There's a "Cult of Personality" going on there that annoys me. Lots of people acting like sheep and like having faith in the admin is the BEST THING EVAR. I couldn't disagree more. Fuck that. Fuck NeoBux. People who talk shit about the admin or suggest that the referrals are bots are banned. I can understand the reasoning, but it's all getting a bit tiring. It was already drawing close to the BULLSHIT! alert. So, yeah: Fuck NeoBux for now. I'm going to give it one more week, and then I'm gone.

http://ptc-investigation.com/neobux.aspx
greend88
"For some reason I can't get to the Forum on the site every time I try to go to it goes to the Terms and Conditions page.  I submitted a ticket earlier today but no response. Someone asked if their were any other bux sites and Mentioned VcBux and Onbux but didn't give any links. It also filtered the word OnBux lol. I've been paid twice instantly from those two sites in the last month. Also cashed out twice with neobux too but doubt I will ever get to cashout again at this rate."

Uh... so, the admin closed down the forums? I wasn't banned?

Sunday, March 13, 2011

Has NeoBux Committed Suicide?

Seriously. $0.04 is now $0.004?

Check it out:
http://www.neobux.com/forum/?frmid=3&tpcid=192785

Remember when Swagbucks had that *great* idea of giving people more Swagbucks when they searched (while glossing over the fact that everything in the store became 10x more expensive, thus in effect cheapening search credits)? Well, now NeoBux, in my eyes, has become one of the lower-par PTCs. What do I mean by that? I mean that the clicks are worth $0.001 each. And I mean the "Fixed advertisements".

I mention this because this could potentially mean that I cannot continue the experiment. I've already got an annoyingly large time-scale: 120 days. I can't imagine what a headache this might be if I try that somewhere along the line of 1200 days. What IS that? ... It's 3.33 years. ... 3 years. Yeah. I have my hands thrown up in perplextion. I'm going to wait a bit to see if the situation is truly as suicidal as it seems. It simply can't be the case; it doesn't make sense.


Later that day:
http://www.neobux.com/forum/?frmid=3&tpcid=193151
"Discussion on latest changes."

This part of it I find to be hilarious:
"I don't understand why users post something and do the opposite, really. Users claiming that they'll leave and they've been around all day clicking each new advertisement, for example."
Being a moron? Yeah, they're going to leave after they've been able to make cashout, after they've confirmed that the earnings are so low it's not worth it. Yeah, they're clicking away because they're in panic, you moron!

"Now that most of them have actually seen that they've misunderstood how things will work, I've opened this new topic for users to discuss things in an adult way."
And this is raising red flags for me. Christians say this sort of thing when atheists point out their bullshit. Is this indeed the last days of NeoBux?

"So please, cut the drama since you know that this, as always, will have a good outcome."
Oh yes, as Thou, our Lard, doth tell us. And we are Thy sheep. Fuck that shit.

"So, please, discuss all you want but be fair so that we all can have a nice conversation.
The latest closed topic is something that users that posted certain things won't be proud of in the next days. I'll leave it there as a reminder that we all must read first and think about all possible scenarios."
So, you scold people for not reacting well to getting $0.004 instead of $0.04, and just leave it at that? WTF.

"No one is running away... cashout are there for you if you're scared. Just use the pretty green button and take what's yours as no one will stop you as always."
Ah, so you're a "confidence man".

As you say yourself, you're relying on built-up trust:
"For those who know me by now it's easy to ask for this trust."

And you're not giving any answers. ... Why?

"
 Admin 
 REPLY   QUOTE   + 

 Posts: 12938

Today at 15:15
Quote [Steeps5]:
I did understand the changes correctly. What it means is that we have to do 10 times the work to earn the same amount of money. The value for adds is now 1/10 of what they used to be, showing that it really will take 10 times the work we used to put in.
Yes, that's true and you're not having any misconception regarding it but only for fixed advertisements.
On the other hand, as we've lowered up to 35% the cost of our click packs, there will be a huge increase of advertisements per day. Not only that but we've managed to change what most advertisers left us for: The exclusivity of their advertisements has to be greater than ours.
Since I cannot unveil the new additions right now, I'll stop here.
"
""I did understand the changes correctly. What it means is that we have to do 10 times the work to earn the same amount of money. The value for adds is now 1/10 of what they used to be, showing that it really will take 10 times the work we used to put in."
"Yes, that's true and you're not having any misconception regarding it but only for fixed advertisements.
On the other hand, as we've lowered up to 35% the cost of our click packs, there will be a huge increase of advertisements per day. Not only that but we've managed to change what most advertisers left us for: The exclusivity of their advertisements has to be greater than ours.
Since I cannot unveil the new additions right now, I'll stop here.""

You DO realize that this makes NeoBux very Aurora-like? You DO realize that this makes it lower-par, because people can't click at ads one-shot and be done with them? Those add-ons had better be fuckin' good.

"No one is running away... cashout are there for you if you're scared. Just use the pretty green button and take what's yours as no one will stop you as always."

Well...
"Even if we discuss this in an adult way, the site will keep giving us not even a cent per day, and by the way, you said we just need to click the green button to cashout, how is that possible if i need 20 cents (+ -) to cashout, which will be impossible to achieve with those micro-cents."

"Then you didn't understand it correctly. The rented referrals are still the same amount. So what you're saying is completely false."
So, if you didn't realize, rr (rented referrals) have infamously low click rates. I go on the assumption that they won't click. Kapeesh?

"
Today at 15:19
Quote [send24]:
I will stay here until I reach my next payment because i am close, and after that I will leave!!! So that's the reason we are clicking, and because some members think that this is a joke!!!

THIS IS A RIP OFF AND NOTHING ELSE BUT A RIP OFF.

People have invested over 100$ into your site and now they have to click years and years to return it!
No. No one invested any amount based on the total of own advertisements.
Given that, and to never to those who have invested, their referral earnings will be the same.

The initial idea, since we needed to maintain the same amount of advertisements for rented referrals' commissions, was actually to only give those the fixed advertisements.
Since it would be totally unethical, it was decided to give them to everyone."

Um, what? No one invested based on their own ads? Well, that's just plain false. EVERYONE invested based on having 4 ads a day at $0.01. WTF admin?
And that second part still makes no sense to me. Decrypt it for us, if you would.

Someone attempts to demystify this:
http://www.neobux.com/forum/?/7/193134/Just-attempt-to-clarify-the-news/
"The changes:
You get every click 0,001 Cent. 
If you have directs, you get depending on membership.
- Standard members: $0.0005
- Golden members: $0.005
- Golden members with a Golden Pack: $0.01
Rental value is still the same."

Ok. And? It still looks like PTC suicide to me.

"Quote [Icklorfin]:
Yeah, I really don't like how he just had to made the profit for standards worse ;-;. Before you could get 4c for just 4 clicks, now you'd need at least 40 clicks for micro-ads and those fixed ads just to do the same.
thats it. He want to motivate people to invest in neobux to buy members and stay active because of the clicks they must do for getting payed for their members."

So, in other words, buy more referrals... OR ELSE. So, in other words, invest money, OR ELSE. So, in other words, this is becoming a shit sandwich. So, in other words, you're a fuckin' moron, admin.

So: How NeoBux is committing suicide:
http://www.neobux.com/forum/?/7/193134/Just-attempt-to-clarify-the-news/21/
"This is an incorrect understanding. If you rent rent-referrals, and they click 4 ads a day, then you will get $0.02.

THIS is not what the problem is. The problem is that these rent-referrals when they click, they will only earn $0.001 a click, and so if they do not have rent-referrals themselves, they will stop clicking.

Therefore this new payment method will be fine for a while, but when people catch on, the losses will transmit higher and higher up the pyramid.

THIS is the problem with this model!"


"Quote [mrevan]:
as i said alot of users who works for 2$ and cashout they dont have any reffs, but they are the someones refferalls, so if they gonna quit nobody is going to have profitable refferals
No one (or at least not a noticeable amount) of users will quit. If all goes according to my prediction, it will even bring more users.



Quote [helder1986]:
But Admin try to understand some people doesn't have the time to click hours and hours, so because of that ours AVG will drop exponencialy...

Its not a motivation...
It won't take hours.



Quote [comebackdan]:
Legitimate Question - Will Standard users be able to click more than 4 fixed ads per day? I currently am seeing the 15 fixed ads as normal. Will I have 17, 19, 25 in the future?
Depends on the advertiser and maybe a fixed bonus given by us.



Quote [valywanted]:
I think that neobux will lost more members because we have no motivation if we are Standard member.......and Its no faire!!
You'll have plenty motivation, don't worry."

Meh. Waiting in pissed anticipation.

"Quote [RsRoyalty]:
Maybe it would be helpful if you told us all the change. As I had not idea the rented refs give the same amount as before, from the fixed ads, and that would've helped a lot to have known.
It was explained but not emphasized. I sometimes forget that people target bad things faster than good ones with their eyes."

Nah, not really. It's just that if you're looking to commit PTC suicide, that's sort of worrysome. No biggie, though. We can just go to another PTC that isn't into goth. WHAT good ones? Eh? We can't enjoy the good ones if we don't KNOW about them. They're a SURPRISE, remember?

"Quote [willo012]:
admin posing this new thread seems a little immature? what are you some 15 year old kid? im not meaning to be offensive but the facts are many standard members WILL leave because of this silly error and this WILL result in many many member losing out. as a loyal member im asking you to reverse this or please explain properly how this can help anyone because i fail to see what you are trying to do. its a shame to say that you have officially sunk the neobux ship :/
No, but I have good memories of that period a long time ago, thank you.
That's your opinion which comes without facts. I have them."

*cough* "I sometimes forget that people target bad things faster than good ones with their eyes." "That's your opinion which comes without facts. I have them." *cough*
Care to share the facts, all-mighty Zeus?

http://www.neobux.com/forum/?/3/193151/Discussion-on-latest-changes/171/
"Quote [LinkAssist]:
Thanks for giving us a little feedback, Admin. Could you help us out, though? Many are running scared, waiting for the other shoe to fall (or afraid it already has). What new benefits will be upcoming for Standards on Neobux's non-birthday? Can you tell us something that will ease the panic and slow the bleeding?
Keeping my fingers crossed...
Sorry, but you should know by now that a surprise is a surprise."

Sorry, but you should know by now that a seemingly idiotic decision with a lack of visuals of the good stuff results in not good feelings.

"You've noticed it but that's still with the previous price. It takes 24 hours for clicks to be available to advertisers so tomorrow will be different."

*pissed* Good. You'd better hope fuckin' so.

"Although many complaint, the actual truth is that most have been more active today than any other day (and it's Sunday).
They post "it's bad" then realize it's actually good but never say "I was wrong"."
*facepalm*

"Thank you for your concerns, I do appreciate them. Do you really think that I would even a small change if it would hurt NeoBux in any way? I always struggle when making changes due to the fact that a few don't understand them at first. I could just sit back and think "Let them earn only that" instead of thinking "What can I do to make them earn more?". But what can I say? I just can't be passive."
A week's notice would be nice.

"Quote [Govahram]:
This remind me of the demonstrations in middle east and north Africa no offend, you have the Anti-admin and the Admin sympathizers hihi  just kidding 
Please don't make jokes about serious events like that. Thank you."
Oh really? ^_^ Fuck you too, NeoBux Hitman. Oh wait, I meant to say admin. What's the difference, though? :P

Wednesday, February 16, 2011

A Way To Test NeoBux

I've calculated a way to test if it's possible to make money with NeoBux. Yes, I've said that I'm done with PTCs. Apparently, I haven't yet totally convinced myself. I need to know if NeoBux is even potentially reliable. So this is what I've done.

It costs $0.66 to rent the minimum referrals (3).
It costs $3.69 to extend them for the maximum amount of time (240 days).

There are two first problems.

1. How do you deal with waiting, if you're going to click 4 ads per day (108.75 days to get to that)?
2. How do you match up referral sets? That is, how do you deal with the 30 day difference that always occurs?

The solution to problem 1 is that I give money to anyone who might be interested in trying this out, assuming that the current strategy that I'm using works. If it works, then won't I have money to doll out? For me, the solution was that I already had money in my NeoBux from all the experimenting; so, no waiting.
However, assuming that neither of these are true...
Extending 3 refs for 60 more days costs $1.20. During that time (30 days of having the 3 refs you just got), if you've clicked 4 ads per day, you'll have $1.20 (30 * 4). If you haven't, extending 3 refs for 30 days costs $0.21, leaving, hopefully, excess money. Repeating this process will eventually get you up to being able to extend for 240 days each time. Tedious? Yes. But it won't feel as long as the 108 day wait: you're doing something, and you're watching your referrals.

The solution to problem 2 is to separate the 30 from the rest of the equation.
240 (extension) + 30 (initial referral amount) = 270. I couldn't match it up using the 270, but I could with the 240. The plan is to, every 120 days, to check up on how the referrals are doing, see if it's plausible to get more, and then perhaps to buy another set of referrals.

Why will this work?
Gain is greater than cost.

4 * 120 = 480; $4.80. (Assumed gain of clicking every day)
3.69 + .66 = 4.35; $4.35 (Cost of renting new referrals)

Depending on how well the referrals click, I may or may not get many sets. I'm assuming that there won't be a lot of clicking, and I plan to find about where the drop-off is (and if, perhaps, it's computer-generated, and if that means it's engineered to be impossible, and if that means you have to get golden, and whether that means it's a scam or that you "have to put in something to get something out").

So, assuming for not that many new sets:
$4.80 - $3.69 = $1.11. Recycling costs $0.07. $1.11 / $0.07 = 15.857, or 15. That's per 120 days, because that's the refresh rate. So: 15 per 120 days, or 1 per 8 days. So: using this method, you can recycle once per 8 days and have money to make the system go.

I'm also using the paper-and-pen method to record things down. I don't know why, but it just works better for me than the Excel system. The reason I switched is that I accidentally deleted the Excel (trying to use google docs in combination with my hard-drive, making for a transition that... yeah)... and, I'm just really tired of using it. I like to turn pages, too. I just prefer it right now... bug off...

This system should be usable by anyone who wants to investigate the NeoBux PTC.

Monday, December 6, 2010

Why PTCing is a sham

Consider this post not here. Nah, just kidding. This blog isn't exactly dead, but I've absolutely lost my enthusiasm for talking about PTCs, except, of course, if it involves PTC bashing. Which is what this post is about.

ebele tells me she doesn't understand how getting direct referrals is giving someone else the short end of the stick. I posted my answer to the comments section of the last post, and thought it worthy of its own post:
Simply put: Would you, if you had no direct or rented referrals, stay in the PTC you would be collecting direct referrals in? If the answer is no, then what about the people who are without direct referrals, as you get further and further down the line of direct referrals? Eventually, you'll either find someone who doesn't care, and so the whole thing unravels, or who can't get referrals, and so the whole thing unravels. Because, would you stay in if you couldn't get any referrals? If not...
This problem was quintessential with GDI (Global Domains International). It's less evident with PTCs.

How does it unravel? Well, if the person above you is in the PTC business because there are referrals clicking for her and making her money, and the person above that person is doing it for the same reasons, and the person above that person, likewise, and so on and so forth for a good number of people, if the people who are under one of them, way down the line, stops clicking out of boredom (let's just consider that to be not the case for this scenario), or stops clicking because the specific PTC has reached saturation point (everyone's heard about it and everyone's in it), then what about the person who got this last person in as a referral? The person starts losing her direct referrals, which was a good deal of the motivation for clicking (the difference between $30 per month and $1 per month), and so she stops clicking. Oh boy, and what about the person above her? And the person above her? The person above the person that's above her?

You end up with the domino effect, starting from the direct referrals that were at the end of the saturation, and leading up to the very first people who got into the PTC business with this particular PTC.

Supposedly, renting referrals helps with this (so you have more equality in the situation). And, perhaps, it is, if you get one of the packages that cost $90+. And I might try it out just to see if it makes PTCing any less of a sham. But I thought the idea was to not spend money on PTCs? Well, it's not like it would be any worse than $200+ on bux.to... *shrugs*

Friday, October 8, 2010

So I finally caved in...

And recycled the 3 referrals. Interestingly, the clicks of the "fresh" referrals were instantly at 4, though off and on. I find this to be curious, and it makes me wonder, if this is going to be a consistent thing, what a healthy recycle ratio might be. I.e., is there a way to assume recycling to be the case, and still, overall, be able to make a profit? At what point should recycling happen, and will that make for sustainable growth? This will be the next question I explore in relation to PTCs and NeoBux.


9/24/2010 3 2
9/25/2010 3 1
9/26/2010 3 2
9/27/2010 3 2
9/28/2010 3 2
9/29/2010 3 1
9/30/2010 3 1
10/1/2010 3 2
10/2/2010 3 2
10/3/2010 3 1
10/4/2010 3 2
10/5/2010 3 -190
10/6/2010 3 12
10/7/2010 3 8
10/8/2010 3 8
(Legend: the recurring 3 stands for the number of referrals. To get the average clicks, divide the number that follows after the 3, by 3, because it's the sum of all 3 referrals.)
(The -190 just means that I recycled the referrals, and that's the resultant number from all the build-up. Apparently the total number of clicks from them was 190.)

Tuesday, September 28, 2010

NeoBux Renting Rescue: The Fundamental Flaw

The problem with trying to direct referrals is that of basically being
a spambot and creating an unsustainable MLM matrix:
there's inevitably going to be a loser, if not many.

However, this problem is not eliminated with renting.
Instead, it's put off a bit down the line. Especially with
NeoBux, you're not pushing people to click. The clicking
is dependent on whether they want to get the clicks
from their referrals. All well and good.

Here's the problem: You can rent more than one person.
And that person can only be rented to you.
That means that that person can't be rented to anyone else.
And that means that if someone has all of the rents,
then no-one else can rent.

Let's just say everyone in the world who was on NeoBux
was rented to 10 people. What does this mean for the other
non-10 people? That means that there's no incentive to click -
whose clicks are you trying to get?

Thus, it seems, unless there's an equal distribution of who
gets the clickers, the system will implode. And even with
an insane thing like regulating NeoBux -- growth can only
come from getting more clicks, and getting more clicks
comes from getting more users. This fundamentally limits
the system. You just get the direct referral problem happening
later on, in a more dispersed and abstract way.

So - the fundamental flaw: people can only be rented to one
person at a time. Which is great for the people who got into the
system really fast. But soon, the people who are clicking to
get their referral clicks will notice a decline in the referral
clicks (because the referrals aren't getting clicks from the
people THEY rented), and accordingly, will become rather
demotivized and probably stop clicking.

And guess how that'll end up?

Even in the best-case scenario where everyone clicked 4 ads
each day, the only way to get more clicks is to invite more people
into NeoBux so you can use their clicks. And why will they
click? Who knows -- everyone's already rented to someone! (theoretically)


What's the solution?

I'll take a stab: a system that is integrated with something else,
probably a social networking site or something. Like a facebook
NeoBux or a Gmail NeoBux, or something like that. In a similar
vein as Swagbucks, where the company provides incentives to
look at otherwise-annoying ads. Now, because those ads are
being seen, you've gotten exposure to product x. And so it
would in that way be a win-win scenario.

Sunday, August 29, 2010

A Dying Trend?

Well howdy. It's almost been a month.

What have I been doing? Not much. Lots of relationship stuff.

I've been doing NeoBux, mainly. I'm wanting to do other PTCs
as well, or something else at the least, but it looks like the only
reliable PTC that has a rental system is NeoBux.

Gomez, Swagbucks, and NeoBux. And frankly, the money
so far hasn't exactly been that fast. Money from Swagbucks
has helped here and there, though.

My initial guess regarding NeoBux was to do with the
following calculations:
- 4 clicks per 3 referrals (break-even standpoint)
- How long this would take to reproduce more referrals who, in turn, make me enough money to
- Rent more referrals

A Standard member in NeoBux can have 300 referrals.

My calculation was thus this:

If there is a total and overall average of 4.1 clicks per
3 rentals, then after you make enough profit to rent referrals
and get to 300, you'll make a
daily profit of $8.10, a
monthly profit of $243, and a
yearly profit of $2956.50.

And the time in total to get to this would be
142 days.

Not exactly great, but then, it's a whole lot better
than investing 6 months of excitement, anticipation,
and around $200 into a site like bux.to!

Not too shabby, but indeed based on an assumption,
and an important one:
A 1.37 click ratio.

The next step has been to see what I'd actually get,
and adjust expectations accordingly.

Unfortunately, the ratio I've been getting have been
a lot lower than what would be needed. 1.14, and trending
downward. The reason, of course, is that I'm not recycling.
At all. Mostly because I'm curious of what will happen if
I keep the rental. Will the rental become active? Stay dormant?
For how long?

Since the renew prices have changed, and more types
of renews have been added, I've revised my approach
to being a bit more indecisive as to what to do next.
I both want to have a high average - as high as possible,
and I want to observe clickers. My approach to this before,
I suspect, was to over-recycle. Or maybe it wasn't -
I don't really know.

Additionally, having referrals who don't click - and click
less - is really boring. I'm finding myself less and less interested
in continuing, so I think I've going to soon recycle them,
if not just to make it so I don't lose hope (hey, it's my blog;
I can be melodramatic if I want).

But yeah. Everything otherwise, this internet stuff is
looking pretty shitty. If nothing else, when I get another
job I'll maybe use some extra money to speed the NeoBux
process along and find out this stuff faster, but that's about
all I'd do.

Maybe there aren't any decent PTCs. Or maybe I do just
need to upgrade to Golden, and that will change things.
*shrugs*

Tuesday, August 3, 2010

PTC Relapse... again

Alright. So I said I was done with PTCs, right?
That's what I said however-many-years-ago
after I spent around $200 on bux.to and got
$10 back.

And I was done with PTCs... for about a year or so.
Then I came back to check them out, and found
that NeoBux had started up about 6 months
earlier.

What can I say? I'm a PTC addict. I want an
easy way to make money. It doesn't necessarily
have to be fast, but it does have to be reliable,
and preferably have a high potential. Within
reasonable limits, of course, in order to avoid
wasting an exuberant amount of time, and in
order to avoid getting scammed (Ok, really,
just to make it less likely. In the PTC world,
scam in the norm; you just move on).

For example, the payout has to take less than
something like 60 days - otherwise paypal
won't refund it. I heard that from somewhere.
Makes sense.

Early on I realized that getting direct referrals 
for PTCs was not the way to go. Why?
Because it results in a pyramid scheme.
How? Think of it:
You're trying to get direct referrals so you
can make money. Which means that you're
not making money as it stands. Why would
your direct referrals want to join unless they
could make money? And how would they
make money? Through getting direct referrals.
And how would those referrals make money?
By getting direct referrals.

What a piece of shit. No wonder it's hard
to get direct referrals.

(I got a comment from Cameron on one of
my older posts - the one about NeoBux's
autopay, where he said that he linked the
post to his Top3-Pay-to-Click blog - which
he did. On that same page was the traditional
spreadsheet of direct referral earnings:
... and, my apologies. I mis-saw what
was there. Anyway, I can skim it off of
bux.to's website anyway:

"Earnings Example
» You click 10 ads per day = $0.10
» 20 referrals click 10 ads per day = $2.00
» Your daily earnings = $2.10
» Your weekly earnings = $14.70
» Your monthly earnings = $63.00"

And how does bux.to accomplish this feat?
By using bots: (from PTC-I)
http://img16.imageshack.us/f/bots30547516jq3.jpg/

I'll revisit this in a moment.)

Hence the allure of NeoBux: you rent refs. 
Not buy them, as with bux.to. Not convince
family, friends, and make business cards for
random people you might meet (yes, I did do
that - I got bux.to business cards from Vista
Prints. Wow, right?). But just pay a certain
amount as per which way you decided to
pay (30 days, 60 days, 90 days, autopay...).

The question then becomes: is renting refs profitable?
The answer? I don't know. That's what I'm trying to
figure out. And the answer might be thus:
After two years, with consistent reinvestment to
get more refs until you hit the standard limit of 300,
it won't be profitable. Two years sounds like a long-shot
to me. But seeing as I've spent that much time trying
to find a decent PTC anyway, it just might be something
to consider.

I mean, it's not like I won't still be looking out of curiosity,
even after I've sworn that I've stopped doing PTCs for
here now and forever, so I might as well do NeoBux on
the side. If nothing else, I could spend two years investing
nothing into NeoBux, manage the referrals, and come back
with the report.

So it looks like the key to having a successful referral system
would be to rent referrals. If this can be profitable for those
doing the renting, then the system basically sells itself, and the
direct referrals that would occur from people sharing wouldn't
be people trying to make money off their friends, but money on
top of their intended means of making it.

And that's why I only consider either PTCs that have a ton
of ads to click (at a decent rate, which means at the very
least about $0.0003 per ad), or to have a rental system.
Otherwise it's simply not worth the hassle of weeding through
the 90-99% of PTCs that go bad. Other people can do that,
and then you can search for which PTCs rise to the top,
and maybe include those in your base. Or not. *shrugs*

One thing I really liked about paidtoclick.in was the automated
payments. All I had to do was click, daily, on the ads. It was -
for the most part - a steady stream of income. Yes, it was about
$0.02 per every 3 days, or something like that, but it was reliable.
It was certainly better than $0 per day for looking for more PTCs
that didn't work.

So another method that I employ is that of finding low amounts
in a short period of time. Here, again, is a system where you
could find some direct referrals who might be interested in joining.
And then that could be incremental.

Overall, what have I found so far?
NeoBux, Swagbucks, Gomezpeer, and YouData.
Only one of those is a traditional PTC. I say "traditional"
because technically YouData is a PTC, but its style is
much different from what a PTCer would expect.


So, the second part: What's the problem with renting? 
Accusations of NeoBux using bots usually become posts
that are deleted. Perhaps understandably, since the reaction
to this would be, probably, panic. Things like, "Has NeoBux
finally gone scam" might come up. Then again, perhaps the
admin actually IS using bots, and that's why the posts are deleted.

The problem with renting is that the average tends - or has tended -
to be very low. I guess it doesn't really make sense that the users
are bots, in that way, since, with sites like bux.to, you were pretty much
guaranteed to have a high click rate - but ah, until the ref reaches
around 300 clicks. Then it's a dead fish.

Which is why the craziness of some refs is troubling. It seems,
sometimes, that a referral would be active for a few weeks,
and then the average would just drop, or become non-existent.
This has been what has been behind the almost Tessa-like
declaration from people trying of "Well, you've either got it or you don't."
(Tessa has a scheme where you can take three steps and join a
bunch of stuff and he'll promise you $125. When you complete the
steps, if you don't read the fine print, you realize that you need $200
to cashout. And in order to get that you need to do some heavy
marketing... or... something. Hence, it's a friggin' pain in the ass,
and almost guaranteed to not work if you don't know what you're
doing. I didn't. Lost a few bucks on that...
Reminds me a little of GDI, and GDI reminds me a little of FHTM.
GDI stands for Global Domains International.
FHTM stands for Financial Hi-Tech Marketing.
Both have great referral schemes, but if you don't like the product
(and the products for each isn't so great), then the whole
program falls apart.)

So, I think that'll be my homework to myself (which I'll probably
do out of sheer PTC-addiction), to figure out this renting
referral thing, and how I can make it profitable for myself
and others. Numbers are one thing. Behavior is another animal
entirely. I got about $1.50 built up before I rented 3 refs;
a little lower than is recommended to start, but I sort of just
want to observe the 3 referrals more than anything else.
I was getting bored with just clicking 4 ads per day.

So. There you have it. I'm addicted. :-( :-P
Not to say that I'm not still looking into other
methods. This post is specifically about PTCs
and NeoBux.